Why Integrated Business Planning is Vital for Business Growth

Why Integrated Business Planning is Vital for Business Growth

Imagine modern Integrated Business Planning (IBP) as a comprehensive fusion of supply chain optimization, financial planning and analysis (FP&A), and operational best practices. It’s driven by a companywide culture focused on delivering the speed, savings, and responsiveness that today’s consumers demand while effectively managing risk.

Although IBP has long been perceived as a jargon-heavy process typically implemented by costly consultants for large global corporations, it remains an essential tool. These corporations often seek to unify siloed sales, supply, financial, and operational resources to stay competitive against more agile rivals that could push them off the Fortune 500 list.

However, IBP is worth reconsidering for any company aiming to maximize profits and minimize growth-related risks. And the best part? You don’t need a six-figure consultant to get started.

What Is Integrated Business Planning?

Integrated Business Planning (IBP) is a strategic approach that aligns a company’s business goals with its finance, supply chain, product development, marketing, and other operational functions. Imagine suppliers working with automakers needing constant retooling to accommodate design changes or food producers operating on razor-thin margins managing uncertain supply chains and fickle customer tastes.

Delay in response, and a competitor stands ready to seize that business. Conversely, rapid but uncoordinated action may retain customers but at the expense of higher costs and reduced profitability.

Consider PickerBots, a fictional manufacturer of custom machinery for manufacturing and warehouse operations. Launched in 2017, PickerBots initially found a niche in restaurant supply. However, when that business slowed significantly in 2020, the founders decided to pivot. Instead of merely changing their marketing strategy, they undertook a comprehensive overhaul of their business strategy. A top-down scenario planning exercise led to realigning their R&D, demand forecasting, profitability and revenue analysis, supply chain planning, and marketing and sales strategy.

Although the company culture was strong in innovative thinking, the founders recognized the need to strengthen the link between strategic planning and daily operations. Enter a new COO, an expert in aligning operations with product demand planning, sales and marketing, and financial targets and budgets. This strategic alignment ensured PickerBots could swiftly adapt to market changes while maintaining profitability and operational efficiency.

Key Takeaways

  1. Seamless Integration Across Functions: In a company that fully embraces Integrated Business Planning (IBP), there is a direct and cohesive connection from purchasing, production, and inventory to sales, marketing, financial targets, and budgets.
  2. Optimized Procurement: One of the primary benefits of IBP is the ability to procure materials at the right price, at the right time, and in just the right quantities to meet market demand, ensuring efficiency and cost-effectiveness.
  3. Enhanced Collaboration and Trust: Successful IBP fosters closer collaboration and greater trust among departments, leading to improved decision-making and a more unified approach to achieving business goals.
  4. Cultural Shift and Executive Commitment: Implementing IBP often requires a significant cultural shift within the organization and cannot succeed without unwavering commitment and support from the executive team.

Integrated Business Planning Explained

Many organizations mistakenly view Integrated Business Planning (IBP) as a supply-chain-centric exercise. While integrating supply chain planning with other departments like sales, operations, and finance is crucial, it represents only one facet of IBP.

At its core, IBP aligns business goals and financial targets with decisions and execution across the entire organization, ensuring cohesive and strategic operations.

IBP shares similarities with Financial Planning and Analysis (FP&A) due to its comprehensive data gathering from across the enterprise. This holistic approach enhances predictive analysis capabilities, enabling companies to preemptively address issues such as parts shortages before they impact customers.

IBP is not a one-time initiative. As PickerBots’ new COO suggests, organizations should plan at least 36 months ahead. Leaders must maintain focus on long-term plans while continuously reviewing, revising, and communicating financial and operational results. Questions like, “What supply chain gaps have emerged, and how can we address them?” or “Do we need to update our scenario planning?” and “Are we tracking the right financial KPIs?” are integral to this ongoing process.

A critical component of IBP is the integration of financials with operations. Here is the structure that PickerBots plans to follow:

  • Long-Term Vision: Setting strategic goals that span a minimum of 36 months.
  • Continuous Review: Regularly revisiting financial and operational outcomes to ensure alignment with strategic goals.
  • Proactive Adjustment: Addressing supply chain and operational gaps promptly to prevent disruptions.
  • Collaborative Decision-Making: Fostering interdepartmental collaboration to enhance trust and improve decision-making.
  • Executive Commitment: Ensuring unwavering support from the leadership team to drive cultural change and successful IBP implementation.
infographic-integrated-business

Why Is Integrated Business Planning Important?

Companies that implement Integrated Business Planning (IBP) gain numerous practical benefits, including reduced holding costs, enhanced customer service and demand fulfillment, quicker time to market for new products, and better alignment between demand planning and fulfillment.

Following PickerBot’s scenario planning and strategy session, the company decided to enter the emerging collaborative robot (cobot) market. Collaborative robots are designed to interact safely with human workers. PickerBot’s leaders foresee increased demand for “pick and place” cobots with fine motor skills for manufacturing lines and agricultural settings.

With the strategic direction set, the COO emphasizes three higher-level concepts before delving into more practical areas like financial planning and supply chain optimization. Without goal-setting, PickerBots won’t be able to define success.

Alignment and Accountability

All executives must agree on three fundamental questions: What are our corporate goals? What does success look like for each? How will I and my team contribute and be accountable?

PickerBots’ goals are categorized into four areas: industry-focused, operations and supply chain, financial, and marketing and sales. The management team will review all goals to ensure they align with the strategy and are both actionable and achievable.

Examples:

  • Industry-Focused Goal: Offer the most innovative cobots on the market.
  • What Success Looks Like: Develop a product that can match or exceed a human worker’s ability to pick fragile crops without damage.
  • Who Will Execute: The R&D team.
  • Financial Goal: Diversify revenue streams.
  • What Success Looks Like: Minimize dependence on one market/industry. Add a services arm to generate recurring revenue from maintenance contracts, powered by sensors built into all new products.
  • Who Will Execute: Cross-functional team led by the CEO and finance.

Other goals might include “control costs at each step and deliver cobots to customers on time and to specifications,” with an expectation to lower COGS by 10% and raise the company’s Net Promoter Score by 25% within one year. Or for sales, “find 10 new customers for the company’s agricultural cobots and bundle maintenance contracts with each sale,” tying back to revenue diversification.

An important point: Every manager is accountable for every goal, not just those within their purviews.

Informed Decisions and Actions

PickerBots’ supply chain planning was disjointed, with engineers purchasing materials directly and little central planning or cost control. As part of the IBP process, the company will adopt sales and operations planning (S&OP) principles to improve its supply chain and logistics.

Actionable goals include building visibility into each department’s operations and tying decision impacts to financial goals. For example, by having R&D build in sensors that automatically collect and transmit data on a cobot’s operational status, PickerBots can perform proactive maintenance, minimizing downtime — a crucial selling point and a way to boost maintenance income.

Organization-wide, divisions need to focus less on their own needs and view actions through the lens of all goals. This requires timely data collection and reporting so managers can make better, faster decisions, possibly necessitating investment in ERP and other software.

Transparency and Visibility

All department heads will participate in a monthly business review, assessing progress toward company objectives. The strategic plan will be accessible to all staff, with quarterly all-hands meetings to gather ideas, insights, and walk through KPIs.

Four Success Metrics for the IBP Process Include:

  1. Stakeholder Buy-In: Ensuring all stakeholders understand and agree on corporate goals, with clear responsibilities for each function in achieving these goals.
  2. Data-Driven Decisions: Integrating finance into product, demand, and supply functions, and selecting the right KPIs to base business decisions on data.
  3. Outcome-Linked Decision-Making: Improving accountability by tying decision-making to outcomes, reducing the risk of financial shortfalls impacting the CFO and finance team.
  4. Cultural Shift to Collaboration: Encouraging cross-functional collaboration to build openness and trust, engaging and empowering employees. As an action item, each R&D and manufacturing team member will spend a week annually accompanying sales reps on customer calls.

What Is the Difference Between S&OP and IBP?

The term “Integrated Business Planning” (IBP) was coined by management consultancy Oliver Wight to describe the evolution of the sales and operations planning (S&OP) process, which Wight developed in the early 1980s.

The primary distinction between IBP and S&OP lies in their scope and focus. S&OP has traditionally been the domain of supply chain and logistics specialists, particularly those involved in balancing supply and demand and planning. It is execution-focused, emphasizing a traditional budgeting process.

In contrast, IBP takes a more cross-functional and holistic approach, integrating business goals across all functions. This ensures that supply chain management is not only proactive but also optimized to align with the overall strategic objectives of the company.

While IBP includes the processes of S&OP, it goes further by requiring a cultural shift within the organization. Without executive buy-in and a commitment to fostering this cultural change, the success of IBP is unlikely.

6 Steps in the Integrated Business Planning Process

With its goals set, PickerBots is ready to embark on its Integrated Business Planning (IBP) journey. Here are the six essential steps:

  1. Identify Roadblocks: Determine what is holding the company back. Is it a lack of growth or profitability? Is the product portfolio too complex? Has the business lost its competitive edge? For PickerBots, the primary issue was an overreliance on a single niche market.
  2. Engage and Educate Employees: Leadership’s commitment to goals must cascade through the ranks. Ensuring everyone is committed to IBP is crucial for success. The COO recognizes that a formal employee engagement program is essential to keep workers invested in the business’s success and actively working toward strategic goals.
  3. Set Up a Tiger Team: Successful IBP relies on tight coordination, constant communication, and accountability for KPIs. PickerBots identified engaged employees within each functional area and assigned them to a daily 20-minute standup call. For example, if a shipment of RFID readers needed by manufacturing will be two weeks late, the purchasing team member shares that information promptly. This allows sales to manage customer expectations and finance to account for delayed revenue. If the problem recurs, the company can seek new suppliers, avoiding surprises.
  4. Establish a Project/Product Prioritization Process: Discipline is key in IBP. Only projects that align with the company’s strategic goals receive resources. This might mean phasing out a product line that, while still selling, lacks growth potential. Managers requesting resources or proposing a product/service launch must fill out a cost-benefit analysis template to ensure alignment with goals. Leadership prioritizes using this process, eliminating “sacred cows.”
  5. Expand the Finance Team’s Influence: Finance must be involved in product planning, supply chain optimization, and sales strategy meetings. Specifically, a finance team member well-versed in FP&A functions should be included. FP&A professionals inform major decisions and analyze financial data to create reports on goal achievement. For PickerBots, the head of finance assigns an accounting team member who understands the business and excels in data analysis.
  6. Adopt Technology and Tools to Support IBP: If forecasting is viewed as a quarterly or annual exercise imposed by finance with little benefit to departments, IBP cannot succeed. Companies with static, point-in-time budgets need to adopt rolling forecasts to stay on track. Finance teams must easily access data from each operational area. Both rolling forecasts and better data utilization require technology and a commitment to transparency. After all, you can’t manage what you can’t measure.

5 Tips to Succeed at Integrated Business Planning

Here are some strategies the COO plans to implement to ensure PickerBots’ success with Integrated Business Planning (IBP):

  1. Promote IBP as a Solution to Chaos: Highlight how IBP can bring order to complexity. For example, large companies, particularly those involved in multiple mergers and acquisitions, may have thousands of SKUs and product codes. A major manufacturer working with Oliver Wight used IBP to reduce 120,000 item numbers to about 10,000, cutting inventories by 50% while improving on-time, in-full delivery by up to 20%. For smaller companies, IBP can prevent the need to slash 90% of SKUs in the first place.
  2. Embrace a Continuous Improvement Mindset: Understand that all parts of a production or service system are interconnected, inform each other, and depend on one another for successful outcomes. This mindset originates from Kaizen, a Japanese term meaning “change for the better.” This philosophy emphasizes continuous improvement across all levels, from assembly line workers to the CEO, reinforcing the principles of IBP.
  3. Secure Buy-In from the CIO: Engage the CIO, especially if they have a background in manufacturing IT and are familiar with Total Quality Management (TQM), which aligns with IBP. This will facilitate communicating IBP’s benefits and securing budget for essential technologies such as ERP, enterprise performance management (EPM), supply chain management, and real-time accounting and finance software, which are crucial for achieving the “one set of numbers” value proposition.
  4. Incorporate Risk Management Principles: Acknowledge that disasters, both large and small, are inevitable. While IBP generally focuses on positive outcomes, ensure department heads are conducting scenario planning and what-if analyses to model operational risks, such as overdependence on a single market. Consider assigning your tiger team an additional role as a crisis management strike force.
  5. Involve Human Resources: Labor is likely one of your company’s biggest operating expenses, so ensure it supports your IBP efforts. An HR professional can identify traits in applicants — such as being team players, data-driven, and comfortable with transparency — that predict whether they will contribute to IBP success.

Benefits of Integrated Business Planning

Implementing Integrated Business Planning (IBP) offers numerous advantages, with research highlighting increased revenue as the primary benefit, followed closely by improved forecast accuracy and enhanced Perfect Order Delivery rates.

Here are three additional key benefits:

  1. Real-Time Insights: With the adoption of rolling forecasts, finance teams can answer questions about spending and cash flow more quickly and accurately. This leads to more precise Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) across the board, enabling better decision-making and more agile financial management.
  2. Ownership and Accountability: In a company fully embracing IBP, all employees take responsibility for achieving goals. To support this, decision-making authority must be decentralized and linked to accountability for outcomes. This prevents the demoralizing effect of accountability without the power to drive success. Companies can further foster a culture of ownership by tying rewards to the achievement or surpassing of goals.
  3. Improved Customer Satisfaction: Beyond ensuring more on-time, in-full deliveries, IBP enhances customer satisfaction by providing better insights into customer needs. This improved understanding, coupled with a strong company culture, boosts customer empathy, leading to higher Net Promoter Scores and overall customer loyalty.

Integrated Business Planning Adoption Challenges

The starting point for adopting Integrated Business Planning (IBP) depends on a company’s maturity level. Businesses with competitive cultures and highly siloed processes face significant challenges. These are often firms with traditional top-down management structures, static annual budgeting with limited capacity for forward-looking projections, and outdated business plans misaligned with current customer needs.

While these structural issues are challenging, an even greater obstacle is a leadership team unwilling to decentralize decision-making authority. Companies with autocratic, command-and-control styles must be open to decentralizing authority to realize IBP’s benefits.

Even businesses with mature, integrated processes and egalitarian cultures can struggle with “top down” versus “bottom up” KPI reporting and budgeting. IBP necessitates a shift from finance developing a top-line budget and handing it down to departments, to a bottom-up process where departments create plans, calculate costs, and provide this information to the finance team to compile the total budget.

Companies not using flexible budgeting processes may find this shift difficult. One way to initiate the transformation is through a modern form of zero-based budgeting (ZBB).

Steps for Zero-Based Budgeting in 2024

  1. Create a Strategic Vision for ZBB: Identify cost targets, relevant KPIs, and goals.
  2. Evaluate Business Units: Select ZBB candidates, also known as “decision units,” which are independent business organs with their own budgets.
  3. Start Budgets from Zero: Each decision unit starts from scratch.
  4. Provide Decision Packages: Break down each activity in terms of objectives, funding needs, justification in the context of company goals, technical viability, and alternative actions.
  5. Evaluate Each Proposal: Determine each item’s value-add and justify its cost based on company goals.
  6. Prioritize Costs: Allocate funds to areas that align with the business’s growth drivers and reduce expenses in less productive areas.

Elements of Integrated Business Planning

IBP typically operates on a regular cadence, often monthly. These steps, adaptable to most industries, include PickerBots’ COO’s cycle of market research, strategic planning, R&D, manufacturing, demand forecasting, profitability analysis, supply chain optimization, and marketing and sales strategy.

  1. Product Management Review: A cross-functional team meets monthly to review the status of product-related projects, ensuring alignment with business goals. The goal is to align the product portfolio with business objectives and ensure necessary resources are in place. Product managers update the master plan and resource requirements accordingly.
  2. Demand Planning: This cross-functional process helps meet customer demand while minimizing excess inventory and avoiding supply chain disruptions. The team, comprising sales, marketing, and finance members, optimizes the demand plan. KPIs include sales forecast accuracy, inventory turns, fill rates, and order fulfillment lead times.
  3. Supply Planning: Supply chain experts determine the optimal way to meet projected demand cost-effectively. A formal supply chain visibility (SCV) project helps identify and address weaknesses, such as inventory shortfalls, before they become major issues. The key metric here is lowering the cost of goods sold (COGS).
  4. Integrated Reconciliation: This team consolidates the initial product, demand, and supply plans into one holistic business plan based on a 24- or 36-month projection. They prepare unresolved decisions for executive review.
  5. Executive Review and Rollout: The executive team resolves conflicts and communicates the updated plan to the entire company, ensuring alignment and clarity across all departments.

By following these steps, PickerBots can navigate the challenges of IBP adoption and realize its full potential, from improved forecasting and accountability to enhanced customer satisfaction and operational efficiency.

Integrated Business Planning Components

Integrated Business Planning (IBP) involves three core components: planning, execution, and monitoring and adjustment. The specific actions within each component can vary depending on the consultancy or technology provider. Some IBP solutions focus more on supply chain planning, while others emphasize sales and operations planning (S&OP) or financial planning with integrations into other functional areas. Certain solutions are also tailored to specific industries.

Let’s explore Oracle’s IBPX (Integrated Business Planning and Execution) for Manufacturing solution as an example. Key components include:

  1. Top-Down and Bottom-Up, Driver-Based Planning and Forecasting: This approach combines strategic directives from top management with detailed, ground-level insights from various departments, ensuring comprehensive and realistic plans.
  2. Risk Modeling for M&A and Strategic Initiatives: This involves assessing potential risks and opportunities associated with mergers and acquisitions or other significant strategic projects.
  3. Full Financial Statement Structure for Strategic and Operational Planning: Integrating detailed financial statements into both strategic and operational planning helps maintain financial alignment across the organization.
  4. Predictive and Prescriptive Analytics and Planning: Utilizing advanced analytics to predict future trends and prescribe optimal actions enhances decision-making accuracy and effectiveness.
  5. Pre-Seeded S&OP Process: A ready-to-use sales and operations planning process helps streamline and standardize planning activities.
  6. Near-Real-Time Demand and Supply Balancing: This ensures that supply chain operations can quickly adapt to changing demand conditions, minimizing disruptions.
  7. Real-Time Backlog Management: Effective backlog management allows the organization to address order delays promptly and maintain customer satisfaction.
  8. Automation of Predictions and Corrective Actions Based on Actuals: Leveraging automation to adjust plans based on real-time data ensures that operations remain aligned with current realities.
  9. AI-Enabled Operational Planning: Integrating artificial intelligence into operational planning, such as sales territories and quotas, enhances accuracy and efficiency.
  10. IoT and Sensor Data Flows Integrated with Automated Decisions: Utilizing Internet of Things (IoT) and sensor data to inform automated decision-making processes improves responsiveness and operational efficiency.

For manufacturers like PickerBots, components such as backlog management and enhanced support for IoT and sensor data are critical. Retailers, on the other hand, might prioritize advanced inventory management. Regardless of industry, any IBP solution should facilitate long-, medium-, and short-term planning based on a single, up-to-date data set accessible to all authorized stakeholders.

Additionally, look for the ability to easily model “what-if” scenarios, robust budgeting and costing, and a roadmap to advanced technologies like AI and predictive analytics. These features are essential for maintaining flexibility and staying ahead of market changes.

Integrated Business Planning Examples

One notable example of successful Integrated Business Planning (IBP) implementation is the Uponor Group, a Finnish company specializing in drinking water delivery products and radiant heating and cooling equipment. After a series of acquisitions, Uponor faced challenges with swelling inventories, a complex portfolio, and a lack of communication between siloed functions and geographically dispersed locations. The company, with 3,900 employees in 30 countries, struggled to achieve a unified view of financial information across its subsidiaries, each of which had its own inventory management practices. Small events, such as holidays, would lead to excessive “just in case” inventory, and double-stocking in warehouses was common. Different SKUs for the same items and localized R&D without company-wide collaboration further complicated matters.

Uponor initially focused on its supply chain, implementing Sales and Operations Planning (S&OP) processes before advancing to IBP the following year. The results were impressive: a €1.1 billion increase in net sales, a 30% improvement in on-time, in-full deliveries, a 50% reduction in inventories, and enhanced visibility across the organization.

Another example is U.S.-based technology provider Juniper Networks, which undertook an IBP project to implement a digital supply chain. Juniper extended its business planning process to encompass S&OP throughout its supply chain, product and customer portfolios, customer demand, and strategic planning.

Since implementing IBP, Juniper has seen a 55% improvement in lead-time attainment and a 15% reduction in inventory costs, resulting in a positive ROI on the IBP project. These examples illustrate the transformative impact of IBP on diverse industries, demonstrating how a well-executed IBP strategy can streamline operations, improve financial performance, and enhance overall business efficiency.

History of Integrated Business Planning

Integrated Business Planning (IBP) has its roots in the 1980s when Oliver Wight developed Sales and Operations Planning (S&OP) as a methodology to help clients balance supply and demand volumes. Over the years, the process evolved to encompass financial integration, inventory management, and new product introductions.

In the late 1990s, the consultancy rebranded S&OP as Integrated Business Planning to reflect its broader scope, which aimed to integrate all business functions into a single, optimized plan. This rebranding signified a shift from a purely operational focus to a more holistic approach that includes strategic alignment across the entire organization.

In recent years, the concept has further evolved into “Enterprise Integrated Business Planning” (EIBP). EIBP expands on traditional IBP by incorporating scenario planning and extended supply chain collaboration. It also emphasizes how large companies can adopt emerging technologies such as artificial intelligence (AI), big data, and advanced analytics to enhance their planning processes.

This evolution demonstrates the growing complexity and sophistication of business planning methodologies, highlighting the need for integrated approaches that leverage modern technology to drive efficiency and strategic alignment.

Applications of Integrated Business Planning

Integrated Business Planning (IBP) enhances transparency in planning and operations, making it ideal for companies transitioning to “just in time” manufacturing. Its predictive capabilities, once sufficient data is accumulated, significantly improve customer satisfaction.

For instance, PickerBots identified a recurring issue with constrained supply chain capacity for motherboards in Q3. With this insight, the sales and marketing teams can incentivize customers to take deliveries in Q2 or Q4, the manufacturing team can prebuild products, and supply chain leaders can secure alternate sources for critical parts.

Future Applications of IBP

Looking ahead, IBP is poised to help companies in several key areas:

  1. Long-Range Strategy Planning and Modeling: Companies can undertake longer-range strategic planning, including mergers and acquisitions (M&A) activities, with greater confidence.
  2. Proactive Event Detection: Advanced technologies such as real-time sensor data and machine learning (ML) pattern recognition will enable companies to detect and notify stakeholders of unanticipated events before they impact the business.
  3. Automated Decision-Making: As companies grow more comfortable with automation, advanced IBP systems can autonomously take action based on analysis. For example, a bakery chain’s IBP system might detect a tropical storm forecast that could increase vanilla prices and automatically order extra supplies.

Technological Foundations

Cloud-based technologies, such as Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) systems, underpin these advancements. For example, PickerBots traditionally set monthly sales goals, but these plans often faced delays due to executive reviews, leaving operations in the dark. A tool like NetSuite Planning and Budgeting automates planning processes and centralizes financial and operational data, allowing finance teams to quickly disseminate updates.

Extending IBP to External Partners

The next frontier for IBP involves extending it to business partners, suppliers, and even customers. However, companies must first ensure their internal cultural and technological frameworks are robust enough to support this expansion.

By leveraging IBP, companies can not only streamline their internal processes but also create a more responsive and adaptive business environment, ultimately driving better performance and customer satisfaction.

Summary
Why Integrated Business Planning is Vital for Business Growth
Article Name
Why Integrated Business Planning is Vital for Business Growth
Description
Uncover how integrated business planning enhances business transparency, predictive capabilities, and strategic alignment with emerging technologies.
Publisher Name
ABJ Cloud Solutions
Publisher Logo